Ensuring Health, Safety and Continuity Amidst COVID-19. Click here to learn how Nesco Resource is Responding.


Associate Portal

“Why Shouldn’t We Hire You?” Trick Question, or Opportunity to Impress?

You’re at a job interview. Everything is going well, until the interviews hit you with the following question: “Why shouldn’t we hire you?”

It’s easy to feel nonplussed by this question. After all, every effort in a job interview is to convince the hiring managers to hire you, not the opposite.

Trick question…

Well, from the hiring manager’s perspective, that’s one of the reasons to ask the question. Interviews can get a bit rehearsed, as candidates put forth their qualifications and past achievements. A slightly startling question is a chance for them to see how you think on your feet.

So partly, this particular gambit is a trick question. First, you have to understand it. Yes, they’re asking why they shouldn’t choose you for the job.

…and opportunity to impress

But it’s important to realize that it’s not only a trick question, too.

The question is another way of asking an old interview stand-by, “What’s your greatest weakness?”

There are two tried-and-true ways to answer both the questions.

Method 1

The first is to turn the question around, so that you are answering it — naming a weakness — but taking care to name a weakness that employers see as a strength.

The classic answer was always “My weakness is I work too hard,” and then examples of devotion to your job.

Currently, that answer is considered too much of a cliché. But you use the concept. You turn it around and answer with a strength.

You might answer “Why shouldn’t we hire you?” by emphasizing your devotion to task completion — and de-emphasize another quality that is not important to the job anyway.

For example, you might answer “You shouldn’t hire me if you want someone whose strength is speaking in public. I can do it, as my performance at the XX Conference shows, but I’m far stronger in motivating a team with hands-on methods every day. As my work with the team dedicated to cloud computing showed…”

Method 2

The other way to answer the question is to name an actual weakness. Be careful with this one, though. You don’t want to give interviewers an answer that may make them think twice about hiring you.

Choose a weakness you’ve had in the past that you realized wasn’t working for you, for example, so you worked to overcome it. Or choose a weakness unrelated to your job.

In the first instance, you might answer “You shouldn’t hire me if you want someone who double-checks every piece of data going through the team. Earlier in my career, I was a perfectionist who dotted every ‘i’ and crossed ‘t.’ But as I’ve moved up, I’ve realized the importance of time-management and focus on my tasks. Now I leave the double-checking to the person on the team responsible for that.

In the second, you might answer “You shouldn’t hire me if you want someone who is great at small talk. While I like socializing with new people, I prefer to stick to close associates and my team.”

A staffing agency that works for you

Interviewing is crucial to a job search. For more tips on answering interview questions, contact Nesco Resource today.

Previous Posts

Tips for Making Your Temporary Job Permanent Have You Experienced a Career Setback? Here's How to Rebound Work Your Way to the Top With These Tips IT Addictions and How to Overcome Them What is Killing Your Productivity as an IT Professional? The Top Five Lessons People Have Learned Throughout Their Career Top Three Skills Needed to be a Successful CAD Technician How to Properly Prepare for an IT Job Interview Three Ways to Invest in Your Professional Skill Set How to Build a Personal Five Year Plan What Type of Resume Format is Best for You? Tips for Building Your Personal Brand While Looking for a Job The Best IT Certifications to Help You Advance Your Career What You Shouldn't Say During a Job Interview How to Choose the Best Job Reference Here are the Best-Paying IT Jobs for Every Stage of Tech Careers Why We are the Best for Engineering Staffing and Recruiting Are You Prepared to Reach Your 2018 Career Goals? Perfect! How to Tell if You Work for a Really Great Company How to Properly Follow Up After Submitting a Resume Having a Portfolio Will Help Boost Your Engineering Career Top Five Things You Should Never Say During a Job Interview How to Get Your Resume Noticed Quickly Must Have Skills to Succeed as a Project Manager Tips for Success When Attending a Networking Event The Top Skills Needed to be an Administrative Assistant What it Takes to Have a Career in Drafting The Most Important Qualities of a Successful Manager Take Advantage of LinkedIn When Looking for a Job Why Your Company Needs an Expert IT Manager Do You Have a Great Idea to Introduce to Your Company? Here's How to do It How to Advance Your Engineering Career How to Stand Out on Your First Day of Work Why You Should Impress the Receptionist The Benefits of Behavioral Interview Questions Socializing With Co-Workers Can Benefit Your Career Tips for Putting Together a Great IT Resume Tips for Improving Productivity at Work How Following Up Can Help You Land the Job What Employers Look for When Considering a Temporary Employee for a Permanent Position How to Get Involved With the Company Culture as a Temporary Employee How to Bounce Back From a Nasty Interviewer How Recent College Grads Can Network to Find Engineering Opportunities Sharpen Your Game- Tips for All Employees in the Workplace Reasons Why You Should Create Separate Professional Social Media How to Prevent Fatigue During a Lengthy IT Assignment Why a Temporary Position Might Be the Bet Option for a Recent Graduate What You Should Do If You Are Late to an Interview for a Temporary Position Tips on Showing Your Personality in a Professional Interview How to Prepare for Behavioral Questions Picking the Right References What to Ask on the Phone Interview Career Advice for Engineers Have You Googled Yourself? Dealing With Different Interviewers' Personalities How to Network as a Temporary Employee How to Resign Your Temp Job Properly What you Can't Afford to Do in an Engineering Interview 3 Resume Tips for Engineering Candidates Unemployed for a While? Address it in the Interview the Right Way Seeking an IT Position? Market Your Teamwork Skills How To Show Long-Term Interest in an Interview Unemployed for a While? Address it in the Interview the Right Way The Untruths of Temp Myths How To Show Long Term Interest in an Interview Temping Dos and Don'ts 5 Marketable Job Skills You Didn't Know You Had